Executive offer letter: what it leaves out, and what to write down

An executive contract covers title and total compensation. The reasons the executive actually said yes are mostly somewhere else: in what the CEO said about scope, what a director said about authority, what the recruiter said about the team. This page is a list of what to write down.

What the contract leaves out

Offer letters and employment agreements are built to settle pay, equity, severance and restrictive terms. They are not built to record that the new chief commercial officer was told she could hire her own team before launch, or that the new CFO would lead the next financing.

Those statements still count. The executive weighed them when deciding, and will measure the job against them from the first week.

Seven topics to cover

TopicThe question to answer
Reporting lineWho does the executive report to, and who reports to them?
Decision rightsWhich decisions are theirs to make without asking?
ResourcesWhat budget, team or tools were promised, and by when?
First-90-day expectationsWhat does the company expect to see in the first 90 days?
Pay and payment timingWhat was agreed on pay, and when is each part paid or granted?
Working arrangementsWhere and how will they work?
Start date and anything still openWhat is the agreed start date, and is anything still open that could move it?

You do not need all seven. Pick the ones that mattered in this hire. The free promise list builder uses the same topics and produces a one-page list you can print, a template to keep beside the offer letter. Nothing typed into it is saved.

How to write one

  • One sentence, in the words that were used. "Owns hiring decisions for the commercial team within the agreed budget."
  • A date by which the executive should be able to see it.
  • One person on the company side who answers for it.
  • The condition, if there is one: on approval, when the round closes, after the first quarter.

Then send the list to the executive and ask if it matches what they heard. The differences you find at this point are free to fix.

Who made each promise

A senior hire talks to a lot of people before signing: the CEO, future peers, one or two directors, a sponsor, a recruiter. Each of them may have said something the executive is counting on. Ask the executive what they were told and by whom. It is a slightly awkward question and it saves a much worse conversation in month three.

A CEO offer letter is the same problem one level up. The promises that land a new CEO usually come from the board: about authority, the leadership team and how much the board will leave to them. See the CEO onboarding plan for what the board owns.

What to do with the list

Reread it at every review. The executive onboarding checklist shows where it fits from signed offer to day 90. To ask both sides about the promises in the first week, see what a Promise Check is. For a record that runs through the first year, Ros keeps an Appointment File: see the first year after hire.

Common questions

What is an executive offer commitment?
Something the company told an executive they would have or be able to do, as part of persuading them to take the job. Some are in the offer letter. Many were said in an interview or over dinner and exist only in two people’s memories.
What is the difference between an executive offer letter and an employment agreement?
The offer letter usually summarizes the main terms: title, pay, equity and start date. An executive employment agreement is the longer contract, with terms such as severance and restrictive covenants. Neither usually records what the executive was told about scope, authority or resources. Which terms belong in which document is a question for your counsel.
Should these commitments go in the offer letter?
Some companies put a few of them there. Whether to is a legal question this page does not answer. A plain written list that both sides have read is useful either way, because it is what you will reread at the 30-day review.
How many commitments should we write down?
One to 5. If the list is longer, pick the ones the executive would name if you asked why they said yes.
Is a written list of promises a contract?
It is a working record, written in plain words, so that both sides are talking about the same thing later. It is not legal advice and it is not a substitute for the employment agreement.

Start with one hire

Name one executive hire and write the promises you want both sides to answer. A Promise Check is $750, one-time: check-ins on day 1, day 3 and day 7 after the start date, and a dated readout on day 10.

See the Promise Check

More on executive retention